Plot: After spending the night together on the night of their college graduation Dexter and Em are shown each year on the same date to see where they are in their lives. They are sometimes together, sometimes not, on that day.
Mind-numbing, soul-crushing, depressingly dreary, the undeniable stupidity of the human – in particular female – race.
This quote from Perks of Being a Wallflower “We accept the love we think we deserve”. That powerful, terrifying and thought-provoking phrase surely indicates that Emma (Anne Hathaway) does not think she deserves a good man. Emma meets Dexter on the night of graduation. It’s the typical – she crushed on him hard, he’s ignorant to it. He’s had everything given to him in life and is as a result more open to adventures than Emma. Jim Sturgess’ considerable charm is not enough to make rooting for Dexter plausible.
Dexter is beautiful, charming, affluent and a B-grade celebrity in One Day. He’s a jerk, he can’t keep his pants up, and he mistreats his dying mother and concerned father. The only thing good about Dexter is Emma, who for whichever reason remains his friend after rejections and indifference and an unhealthy dose of selfishness from his part. They remain friends for years. She struggles to bloom but eventually reaches her dream of becoming a writer. Dexter, in contrast, loses his B-grade celebrity status because everyone thinks he’s annoying and falls into pit after pit of despair. But no – Emma never realizes that she deserves more. She’s still caught in that University fantasy about the gorgeous man falling for her. No relationship ever works out for her because remains attracted to Dexter. His shitty personality is marginally better when he’s with her, but he only becomes fully saved towards the end of the film, and by that time I just couldn’t care anymore about him.
The script of this film is largely the cause of its’ failure. There is a constant lack of information. Dexter’s mother wants to tell him something, we actually never hear what it was. Is this the cancer she later develops? Is it to tell him she thinks he’s a piece of shit? We aren’t privy to that information and we don’t get to see how it alters Dexter. Dexter’s father is an unsuccessful attempt to be a stoic-but-good man. He’s grouchy and has some moments where he ekes out wisdom, but for the most part he’s an empty character that does nothing for the story. Emma has no family apparently. I didn’t even reach a well of sympathy or gushiness for these characters – the script doesn’t allow you to get there.
Dexter is completely insufferable. Have I mentioned this?! He is the typical and often seen privileged private school kid without morals. I can’t root for him on principle. Not all privileged kids are jerks, but this one certainly is.
Anne Hathaway does her best with Emma, she truly does, but Emma remains a bland, boring and pathetic character without self-esteem and an unhealthy dose of masochism. Anne Hathway can’t pass as a Brit. That accent is off, she rounds her words way too much, and she’s just so American.
I felt like I spent a decade of my life watching this film. It is barely more than one hour and thirty minutes, but so insufferable I’d rather have spent my time watching paint dry.
This film is a drawn out mess about a woman who believes she can save a jerk from himself. The truth is here and that is what irritated me about this film so much – no person can change another person. A person can only change him/herself.
The thing is, I also get platonic relationships that are borderline romantic or full of tension. We all do. There will always be a friend that has the potential for more but there is something holding either of you back at various times. It happens. I just can’t understand why Emma remains friends with such an unredeemable man.
I’m done with this review now. I really hated this film. There are some things that worked – the washed out tones look gorgeous particularly. Other things didn’t work – and most particularly those ugly damn boots Emma insisted on wearing all the damn time.
If you’ve seen this movie, let me know if there is a support group of traumatized watchers helping each other cope with the damage. If you liked it, please do tell me what you liked. I would be VERY curious.
Rating: 4/10
Life of this city girl 
saw it a few years back but dont recall much of it at all. I ranked it 5/10 on IMDB, but i was more forgiving back then 🙂
I understand that – as I watch more and more movies sometimes I find that older movies I remember as good is actually pretty bad haha. 5/10 is quite a decent score for this movie, it was horrid!
I took my ex to see this when it came out. She jumped at the part where Emma gets run over by a truck (or whatever it was). She liked the movie. I don’t really remember it. But now that we’re talking about it, I do vaguely recall going nuclear over that cheesy-as-hell storyline and some seriously manipulative techniques. I don’t remember Jim Sturgess’ character being that much of a shit, but it doesn’t surprise me.
I’m glad someone in the universe actually liked it. I wasn’t too surprised by that, I was just like “eh, more drama in this pile of shit”
Don’t watch it again – it is so stupid and cheesy and you are remembering correctly.
Jim Sturgess’ character made me want to punch a whole in a wall. I probably couldn’t do that, but I wanted to!
“Dexter is completely insufferable. Have I mentioned this?!” – I think I might have picked up on this somewhere. Maybe.
This looks like it was a super terrible film friend, sorry you wasted time sitting through it.
Love the poster
So, just to clarify…you’re not keen on Dexter? Haha!
I’m glad I’ve read this, because I’ve been curious about watching it for a while, and now I know to skip it! Thanks for taking one for the team there 🙂